Bob Graham Education Center in Miami, Florida has become the latest school to ban reading materials from elementary level students in the state. The latest casualty is Amanda S.C. Gorman’s “The Hill We Climb. Gorman became The first National Youth Poet Laureate in 2017. She went on to attend Harvard University, and deliver a poem at President Biden’s 2021 inauguration. The poem contains references to several diverse communities in the United States, including Gorman’s own Black American heritage.
The ban comes after months of restrictive education reform from Governor Ron DeSantis’ desk. What began as the highly controversial “Don’t Say Gay” bill has rapidly spiraled into a national debate on parental rights in public education. The initial bill prohibited any LGBTQ+ inclusive content from being shown in elementary schools. This has now expanded into nude art, including Michelangelo’s David, and now, critical race theory. The latter of which is likely what is responsible for the ban of Gorman’s poem.
In the midst of the educational bans, several states have additionally moved forward to pass bans on drag performances taking place “anywhere a minor can see them” and restricting gender affirming healthcare for minors. Many argue that the bans are becoming too restrictive, while some still voice support for Governor DeSantis’ increasingly conservative views.
Now the poem that Amanda Gorman read at President Biden’s inauguration, entitled “The Hill We Climb,” has been banned from curriculum through 5th grade in Miami-Dade County, for not being suitable for elementary students.
For those who listened to the poem, you would know the… pic.twitter.com/eE38dyIhH4
— Ed Krassenstein (@EdKrassen) May 23, 2023
Others point to the hypocrisy of the school district’s argument. In their attempt to “preserve free speech”, they wind up curtailing the free speech of others. Several parents from the school that banned Gorman’s poem have espoused far-right views on social media.
https://twitter.com/AnonOpsUnited2/status/1661096763372064770?s=20
Online Reactions
Others are asking onlookers to watch Gorman’s live reading of the poem for further introspection. The poem encourages unity, unlike the division it was accused of.
ADVERTISEMENT
Gee, I guess we cant talk about love and unity, either. Such disturbing topics.
— Liquor Morgan (@jack05173883) May 23, 2023
Additionally, some point to this increase in censorship as a reason for Gen Z’s continued activism. Should many of these restrictive bills pass, Gen Alpha may be the first generation in decades to be taught a sanitized version of American history and contemporary politics.
Remember Amanda Gorman, the Gen Z poet who delivered a beautiful poem at the Biden inauguration? Well, Republicans in Miami-dade County, Florida have just BANNED that poem after ONE parent complained it was "inappropriate." I'm telling you: they are terrified of Gen Z.
— Victor Shi (@Victorshi2020) May 23, 2023
One teacher explained the ramifications that the bans could have for young students of color.
Florida’s fascist governor & crew are not only banning books, but more importantly, they’re banning Black students from seeing themselves within an educational system that was never built for them. I teach an Amanda Gorman speech in my freshmen college course, & I’ll never stop! https://t.co/4CULLzOb5T
— Alien Superstar ⭐️✨ (@drhymes_) May 23, 2023
Government Response
Florida Governor Ron DeSantis announced his intent to ban the poem just ahead of tomorrow’s Twitter spaces event, in which he allegedly plans to announce his 2024 presidential bid. The ban felt even more targeted with this information, given that Gorman’s poem was read during a Democratic president’s inauguration.
ADVERTISEMENT
A certain Presidential candidate from Florida just announced he’s banning Amanda Gorman’s poem.
Gen-Z does not f*ck with leaders who ban poems and books. It’s an attack on academic freedom. pic.twitter.com/kCf94oSUEQ
— Gen Z for Biden (@genz_4biden) May 23, 2023
Gorman responded to the ban on Instagram, reiterating the importance of unity and sharing an image of the complaint that led to the ban. The poet encouraged readers to donate to Pen America, which protects writers’ freedoms in the U.S. Her statement was shared via Instagram @amandascgorman.
The poet was met with support from several celebrities in the comments, including actress and activist Sophia Bush. There has been no further comment from other local Florida politicians regarding the ban at this time.
