Summary:
-
A new UK Online Safety Act mandates age verification on platforms like Reddit and YouTube. Implementation is chaotic and controversial.
-
Critics argue facial scans and ID checks are deeply flawed. Age verification laws may lead to censorship.
-
The battle over online age verification laws is about privacy, free expression, and access to information, with global ramifications.
A new chapter in online regulation is unfolding in the UK, and it’s got the whole internet watching. The country’s sweeping Online Safety Act, rolled out this summer, mandates “age assurance” across platforms like Reddit, YouTube, and Discord.
The goal is to shield minors from harmful content, including pornography, pro-anorexia forums, and graphic violence. But the implementation has been chaotic, and its effectiveness remains murky.
Under guidelines from Ofcom, the UK’s media watchdog, acceptable age-verification methods now include facial scans, photo ID checks, and digital identity wallets. YouTube, for example, is deploying AI to guess users’ ages. Spotify is scanning faces.
Critics argue that these systems are not just clunky—they’re deeply flawed. “The UK’s scramble to find an effective age verification method shows us that there isn’t one,” says the Electronic Frontier Foundation. “It’s a threat to privacy, restricts free expression, and leaves millions excluded from access.”
UK’s new age verification laws are preventing anyone under the age of 18 from accessing information on Reddit about Israeli war crimes. Another example of how the goal of these “kids online safety” age verification laws are really only about censorship. pic.twitter.com/Pv74CedCm9
— Taylor Lorenz (@TaylorLorenz) July 27, 2025
The Case For and Against Age Verification
Supporters of the UK’s new age-verification requirements argue they’re overdue. For years, minors have had easy access to adult content—from explicit pornography to harmful advice on self-harm and eating disorders. Under the Online Safety Act, platforms are now legally compelled to enforce age checks, either through facial scans, government ID, or digital identity wallets.
Advocates of the law frame it as a necessary evolution in online safety. The UK government says the act “protects children and adults online” by placing “a range of new duties on social media companies and search services, making them more responsible for their users’ safety on their platforms” (source). It’s also a step toward accountability. Rather than allowing companies to shrug off responsibility, the legislation requires active moderation and compliance.
ADVERTISEMENT
But critics argue the law is already creating more problems than it solves. According to a detailed report in Intelligencer by tech columnist John Herrman, the systems rolled out by platforms like Reddit and Discord are being easily fooled—one instance cited people using screenshots from the video game Death Stranding to bypass facial checks. VPN usage in the UK is reportedly surging as users find workarounds to geo-based restrictions.
Even more concerning is what’s being locked behind these age gates. As reported by Taylor Lorenz, British Reddit users are now required to show ID to access subreddits like r/periods, r/stopsmoking, r/stopdrinking, and r/sexualassault—spaces that serve as essential community support systems, especially for minors seeking help outside their personal networks (source).
Privacy watchdogs are warning that the law goes too far. The Electronic Frontier Foundation put it bluntly: “The UK’s scramble to find an effective age verification method shows us that there isn’t one, and it’s high time for politicians to take that seriously. The Online Safety Act is a threat to the privacy of users, restricts free expression by arbitrating speech online, exposes users to algorithmic discrimination through face checks, and leaves millions of people without a personal device or form of ID excluded from accessing the internet” (source).
The battle over age verification laws is more than just keeping kids safe, it’s about defining the boundaries of online identity, surveillance, and free access to information. As similar laws roll out across the U.S., with Texas leading the charge and the Supreme Court recently upholding its own ID-for-porn law, the stakes are only getting higher.
What’s especially concerning is that the UK may only be the beginning. In July, the U.S. Supreme Court upheld a Texas law requiring age checks for adult sites, bucking decades of precedent. More than half of U.S. states have introduced similar laws. Suddenly, a verified identity isn’t just for banking or travel—it’s becoming a prerequisite for using the internet itself.
“This is not just about porn,” explains journalist John Herrman in Intelligencer. “It’s about a comprehensively different internet… one where, before you can do much of anything, you need to reveal who you are.”
ADVERTISEMENT
For platforms, the age-check mandate also introduces a technical arms race. They must either build new systems or buy third-party tools to scan faces, match IDs, or monitor behaviors—all while maintaining trust and user experience.
Meanwhile, VPN use is skyrocketing in the UK. A tool meant to safeguard children may instead be driving tech-savvy teens deeper into anonymity—and leaving everyone else to navigate a more surveilled, fragmented internet.
