In a recent interview with TIME for the TIME100 Next issue, pop star Sabrina Carpenter shared her experiences with the same type of criticism that has historically plagued female artists in the music industry, including icons like Britney Spears and Christina Aguilera. At just 25, Carpenter has already navigated the complexities of fame and the scrutiny that comes with being a pop artist.
When asked whether she faces similar criticisms as her predecessors, Carpenter affirmed, “No, I definitely get that as well.” She noted that while progress has been made by trailblazers such as Spears, Aguilera, Rihanna, and Madonna, challenges still persist, particularly regarding her stage costumes and personal expression.
Carpenter highlighted the ongoing judgment from some audience members, saying, “But you’ll still get the occasional mother that has a strong opinion on how you should be dressing. And to that I just say, don’t come to the show, and that’s OK.” This sentiment encapsulates her approach to handling critics; she emphasizes the importance of personal comfort in her performance attire, a choice that helps her cope with the pressures of performing live.
The singer of hits like “Nonsense” elaborated on the vulnerability that comes with taking the stage. “It’s unfortunate that it’s ever been something to criticize, because truthfully, the scariest thing in the world is getting up on a stage in front of that many people and having to perform as if it’s nothing,” Carpenter said. For her, the outfits she chooses are not just about fashion; they are about finding the confidence needed to deliver her best performance.
Carpenter also opened up about the impact of social media on her mental health. “Someone told me this: whenever I would get upset or feel like I’m the only one getting criticized for something other people are able to do seemingly so freely, I’m the one that’s seeing all the negative s— about myself. My friends don’t see that,” she explained. This perspective highlights the isolating nature of public scrutiny and serves as a reminder that many artists face similar challenges, even if those challenges are often unseen.
The latest edition of TIME features a heartfelt tribute to Carpenter written by Aguilera, who praised her talent and resilience. Aguilera, now 43, emphasized the importance of not underestimating Carpenter’s capabilities, stating, “It’s the reason she has catapulted to her earned spot as one of today’s leading pop artists. She proves great things come in small packages.” The shared history of both artists, having started their careers at Disney, has fostered a mutual understanding of the demands and pressures associated with the entertainment industry.
Aguilera also expressed admiration for Carpenter’s ability to juggle the various aspects of her career. “Sabrina handles the task with seemingly effortless ease and charisma while promoting, performing, and handling press with a smile and her signature coy charm,” Aguilera wrote. This acknowledgment from a veteran artist underscores Carpenter’s growth and her potential to make a significant impact in the pop music landscape.
ADVERTISEMENT
In the context of today’s music industry, Carpenter’s experiences reflect broader issues of gender and representation. The scrutiny faced by female pop stars is often magnified, creating a challenging environment for personal expression and artistic freedom. Carpenter’s insights into the struggles of navigating criticism provide a valuable perspective on the pressures that young artists encounter as they seek to carve their own paths.
As Carpenter continues to rise in the ranks of pop music, her candidness about the challenges she faces serves as both a reminder and a source of inspiration for aspiring artists. Her journey illustrates the importance of self-acceptance and resilience in the face of adversity, traits that will undoubtedly serve her well as she navigates the complexities of fame and creative expression.
